宗教与历史 （ISSN: 3068-4803）

No. 1 (2025): JSRH
一般论文

Sinicization of Western Learning and the Global History of Knowledge: A Case Study of Huang Baijia’s Comment in Song Yuan Xue’An

PDF (英语)
  • Hao WANG
Hao WANG
Shanghai University

已出版 2025-07-02

关键词

  • Songyuan Xue’an, Zhengshi Lüeshuo, Huang Baijia, Zhu Zongyuan, sinicization of western learning
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

How to Cite

Sinicization of Western Learning and the Global History of Knowledge: A Case Study of Huang Baijia’s Comment in Song Yuan Xue’An. (2025). 宗教与历史 （ISSN: 3068-4803）, 1, 198-219. https://doi.org/10.30250/JSRH.202506_(1).0009

摘要

Huang Baijia has made a lengthy comment on meteorological change in Song Yuan Xue’ an, generally, scholars regard it as Huang Baijia’ s own synthesis of western learnings. In fact, Huang’s comment derived from Zhengshi Lüeshuo, which was written by Chinese Catholic scholar Zhu Zongyuan. Zhu’s book is a work of apologetics; it refers to many Jesuits’ books, such as Taixi Shuifa of Sabatino de Ursis, Huanyou Quan of Francisco Furtado, Kouduo Richao of Giulio Aleni, etc. In Huang’s citation, he pruned all the materials relating to Catholicism while sustaining western secular knowledge. Carefully comparing the valuable copies of Chinese Catholic literature, namely, Zhengshi Lüeshuo of Zhu Zongyuan, Tianjiao Mingbian of Zhang Xingyao, and Xingxue Xingmi of Chen Xun, we can clearly see the western origin of Huang Baijia’s comment as well as his alteration. This provides us with a specific case of the circulation, transformation and sinicization of western learning in the early Qing period, as well as the globalization of modern scholarship.

PDF (英语)

统计

浏览: 19 / 下载: 1

下载

Download data is not yet available.

参考

  1. Aleni, Giulio. 1631. Kouduo richao 口铎日抄 Daily Transcripts of the Oral Clarion-Bell. French National Library, Courant Chinois 7114.
  2. Aleni, Giulio. 1645. Wushi yanyu 五十言余 Book of Fifty Paragraphs. French National Library, Courant Chinois 3406.
  3. Chan, Albert, S.J. 2002. Chinese Books and Documents in the Jesuit Archives in Rome: A Descriptive Catalogue Japonica-Sinica I-IV. New York and London: M. E. Sharpe.
  4. Chen, Xun. n.d.a. Xingxue xingmi 性学醒迷 Studying the Human Nature and Awakening the Bewildered. Two-volume hand-written version, Xujiahui Library, no. 00095795-95796B.
  5. Chen, Xun. n.d.b. Xingxue xingmi 性学醒迷 Studying the Human Nature and Awakening the Bewildered. One-volume hand-written version, Xujiahui Library, no. 00095794B.
  6. de Ursis, Sabatino. 1965. Taixi shuifa 泰西水法 Hydromethods of the Great West. In Tianxue chuhan 天学初函 The First Series of Collectanea on the Theory of Heavens. Book 3. Taipei: Student Bookstore.
  7. Diaz, Emmanuel. n.d. Qingshi jinshu 轻世金书 Chinese Translation of the 'Imitatio Christi'. French National Library, Courant Chinois 7199.
  8. Diaz, Emmanuel. 1642. Tianzhu shengjiao shijie zhiquan 天主圣教十诫直诠 Straightforward Explanation of the Ten Commandments of the Holy Teaching of the Lord of Heaven. French National Library, Courant Chinois 7192.
  9. Dudink, Adrian. 2011. The Chinese Christian Texts in the Zikawei Collection in Shanghai: a Preliminary and Partial List. Sino-Western Cultural Relations Journal XXXIII: 1-41.
  10. Elman, Benjamin A. 2005. On Their Own Terms: Science in China, 1550-1900. Cambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England: Harvard University Press.
  11. Fang, Hao. 1988. Zhongguo tianzhu jiaoshi renwu zhuan 中国天主教史人物传Biographies of Catholic Figures in the History of the Catholic Church in China. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.
  12. Furtado, Francisco. 1628. Huanyou quan 寰有诠 Chinese Translation of Aristotle's 'Cosmology'. French National Library, Courant Chinois 3384.
  13. Gong, Yingyan. 2006. Mingqing zhiji de zhedong xueren yu xixue明清之际的浙东学人与西学 [Eastern Zhejiang Scholars and Western Studies in the Ming and Qing Dynasties]. Zhejiang Daxue Xuebao (Renwen Sheke Ban) (3): 60-8.
  14. Han, Qi. 2018. Tongtian zhixue: yesu huishi he tianwenxue zai zhongguo de chuanbo 通天之学：耶稣会士和天文学在中国的传播 Knowledge of the Cosmo: Jesuits and the Spread of Astronomy in China. Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company.
  15. Huang, Yinong. 2018. Zhi tianming er yong: xingzhan, shushu yu zhongguo gudai shehui 制天命而用：星占、术数与中国古代社会 Astrololy, Divination and Ancient Chinese Society. Chengdu: Sichuan People's Publishing House.
  16. Huang, Zongxi. 1986. Songyuan xue’an 宋元学案 Scholarly Annals of Song and Yuan Confucians. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.
  17. Li, Tiangang. 2007. Kuawenhua de quanshi: jingxue yu shenxue de xiangyu 跨文化的诠释：经学与神学的相遇 Intercultural Interpretation: The Encounter of Confucian Classics and Theology. Beijing: New Star Press.
  18. Liu, Yunhua. 2009. Qingchu ningbo wenren de xixueguan: yi huang zongxi wei zhongxin lai kaocha 清初宁波文人的西学观：以黄宗羲为中心来考察[The Western Learning of Ningbo Literati in the Early Qing Dynasty: An Examination Centred on Huang Zongxi]. Historical Review (3): 54-61.
  19. Lu, Dian. 1936. Piya 埤雅 Aid to the Ready Guide. In Congshu jicheng chubian 丛书集成初编 First Anthology of Books from Various Collectanea. Book 1173. Shanghai: The Commercial Press.
  20. M., D. E. 2002. Book Review of Dominic Sachsenmaier’s Die Aufnahme europäischer Inhalte in die chinesische Kultur durch Zhu Zongyuan (ca. 1616—1660). Sino-Western Cultural Relations Journal XXIV: 70-2.
  21. Sachsenmaier, Dominic. 2018. Global Entanglements of a Man Who Never Traveled: A Seventeenth-Century Chinese Christian and His Conflicted Worlds. New York: Columbia University Press.
  22. Standaert, Nicolas. 2012. Chinese Voices in the Rites Controversy: Travelling Books, Community Networks, Intercultural Arguments. Roma: Institutum Historicum Societatis Iesu.
  23. Standaert, Nicolas et al. ed. 2013. Xujiahui cangshulou mingqing tianzhujiao wenxian xubian 徐家汇藏书楼明清天主教文献续编 Sequel of the Ming and Qing Dynasty Catholic Literature from the Xujiahui Library Collection. Taipei: Taipei Ricci Institute.
  24. Vagnoni, Alfonso. 1637. Huanyu shimo 寰宇始末 The Beginning and the Ending of the Universe. French National Library, Courant Chinois 6859.
  25. Vagnoni, Alfonso. 1633. Kongji gezhi 空际格致 Meteorological Studies. Waseda University Library, no. ニ07 02288.
  26. Wang, Hao. 2020. Wang honghan fengjiao jiqi xiangguan wenti 王宏翰奉教及其相关问题 [The Christian Belief of Wang Honghan and Related Questions]. Christian Scholarship (23): 149-65.
  27. Wang, Sanpin. 1987. Gujin shiwu kao 古今事物考 Research of All Things from Ancient Times to the Present Day. Shanghai: Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House.
  28. Xiao, Qinghe. 2015. “Tianhui” yu “wudang”: mingmo qingchu tianzhujiao qunti yanjiu “天会”与“吾党”：明末清初天主教徒群体研究 “Christian Communities” and “Our Comrades”: A Study of the Catholic Communities in the Late Ming and Early Qing Dynasties. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.
  29. Xiao, Qinghe. 2019. Tianru tongyi: qingchu rujia jidutu yanjiu 天儒同异：清初儒家基督徒研究 As Confucian and As Christian: A Study of Confucian Christians in the Early Qing Dynasty. Shanghai: Shanghai University Press.
  30. Xie, Guozhen. 1982. Mingmo qingchu de xuefeng 明末清初的学风 Academic Styles in the Late Ming and Early Qing Dynasties. Beijing: People's Publishing House.
  31. Xu, Haisong. 2000. Qingchu shiren yu xixue 清初士人与西学 Scholars and Western Learning in the Early Qing. Beijing: Oriental Publishing House.
  32. Xu, Haisong. 2005. The Eastward Spread of Western Learning and the Eastern Zhejiang School in the Qing Dynasty. In Encounters and Dialogues: Changing Perspectives on Chinese-Western Exchanges from the Sixteenth to Eighteenth Centuries. Edited by Wu Xiaoxin. Nettetal: Steyler Verlag, pp. 141-60.
  33. Xu, Zongze. 2010. Mingqingjian yesu huishi yizhu tiyao 明清间耶稣会士译著提要Summary of Translations by Jesuits during the Ming and Qing Dynasties. Shanghai: Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House.
  34. Yang, Xiaoming. 2001. Qingdai zhedong xuepai yu kexue 清代浙东学派与科学 The Zhedong School and Science in the Qing Dynasty. Beijing: China Federation of Literary and Art Circles Publishing House.
  35. Yang, Xiaoming, and Feng Mang. 1996. Huang baijia wulixue chengjiu chutan 黄百家物理学成就初探 [A Preliminary Study of the Physical Achievements of Huang Baijia]. Ningbo Shiyuan Xuebao (2): 26-8.
  36. Zhang, Xiping et al. ed. 2014. Fandigang tushuguancang mingqing zhongxi wenhua jiaoliushi wenxian congkan 梵蒂冈图书馆藏明清中西文化交流史文献丛刊 Series of the Chinese and Western Cultural Exchange History in Ming and Qing Dynasties Literature in the Vatican Library. Zhengzhou: Daxiang Publishing House.
  37. Zhou, Xiefan, ed. 2005. Zhongguo zongjiao lishi wenxian jicheng: dongchuan fuyin 中国宗教历史文献集成：东传福音 Chinese Religious Historical Documents: Evangelism in the East. Hefei: Huangshan Publishing House.
  38. Zhu, Jieren et al. ed. 2010. Zhuzi quanshu 朱子全书The Complete Works of Master Zhu. Shanghai and Hefei: Shanghai Chinese Classics Publishing House and Anhui Education Publishing House.
  39. Zhu, Zongyuan. n. d. a. Zhengshi lüeshuo 拯世略说 An Introduction to the Salvation of the World. French National Library, Courant Chinois 7139.
  40. Zhu, Zongyuan. n. d. b. Zhengshi lüeshuo 拯世略说 An Introduction to the Salvation of the World. French National Library, Courant Chinois 7141.